Thanksgiving with Cooking Club Magazine, 1903

20161007_211750-01.jpegEven though as Canadians we celebrate Thanksgiving in October, I’m blogging about the November 1903 issue of Cooking Club Magazine because it’s pretty much ALL Thanksgiving!  As well as its usual content, it has a Thanksgiving romance story titled Hulda the Help, Thanksgiving recipes and 3 prize-winning Thanksgiving menus.  All the menus feature turkey, cranberry jelly, and a pumpkin dessert, so the basics are quite similar to the traditional Thanksgiving dinner we are all familiar with.  Two of the menus feature oysters, which, judging by other cookbooks of the early twentieth century, were a common Thanksgiving dish.

The first prize went to Edith L. Young, of 314 Baird Ave, Chicago and was “submitted as and old-time Thanksgiving dinner, somewhat modified to suit modern tastes.”  It was specifically intended for rural families without access to city markets, and omits “oysters, elaborate salads, ices and sherbets which figure so largely in our modern Thanksgiving feasts.”

Tomato Soup                     Bread Crisps

Celery                 Pickles

Roast Turkey              Brown Sauce

Cranberry Jelly                   Spiced Watermelon

Mashed Potatoes                 Stuffed Onions


Cold Slaw                    Brown Bread Sandwiches

Mince Pie             Pumpkin Custard


Coffee        Nuts       Raisins

I find this turkey-woman just a little disturbing…. the axe doesn’t help!

This menu suggests roasting the turkey breast side down to result in a moist, delicious breast, and also to sift a teaspoonful of baking powder into the dressing just before filling your bird, to result in a light and fluffy dressing.  Those are 2 tips I plan to try this Thanksgiving.  We are also going to make the succotash recipe from this menu.  There is a different succotash recipe to go with a prize Sunday dinner menu sent in by Mary I. Jennings, of Washington, D.C., and a third recipe in an article titled American Indian Cookery, by Frederick Starr.

Winning menu #2 doesn’t have a name with it, but suggests that the menu should be kept simple, and family and decor should be the main focus.  The menu is clearly stated to not be elaborate, but it seems pretty impressive to me!

Tomato Soup              Croutons

Roast Turkey with Oyster Stuffing

Cranberry Jelly

Mashed Potatoes

French Fried Sweet Potatoes

Baked Squash              String Beans

Celery       Olives       Salted Nuts

Fruit and Nut Salad

Cheese Straws

Pine-apple Souffle


Pumpkin Pie               Cheese

Nuts           Fruit


The third prize was awarded to Mrs. C. S. Van Buran of Elgin, Illinois.  She advises that, if possible, the turkey should be bought alive, though she does have some pointers for selecting a good bird from your butcher.  Her menu, to me, seems completely over the top!

Oysters on the Half Shell

Lemon Points

Brown Bread Fingers

Clear Soup

Salted Pecans                  Pimolas

Roast Turkey                                Garnish

Onions Stuffed with Sausage

Giblet Gravy

Sweet Potatoes and Almond Croquettes


Cranberry Jelly

Chestnut Timbales             White Sauce

Baked Ham                   Cider Sauce

Pumpkin Souffles

Vanilla Ice Cream            Chocolate and Nut Sauce

White Cake            Autumn Fruits


The other two recipes we are making from this magazine are Mystic Pudding, and Cranberry Pudding.  I’ll let you know how they turn out after Thanksgiving dinner!

An old ad.

Mystic Pudding

This pudding was made and named by cooks four or five generations back.  It has not any secret power, but is just this delicious pudding.  Boil one pint of milk.  Stir in four tablespoonfuls of yellow cornmeal and cook ten minutes.  Cool it, add another pint of cold milk, half a cupful of molasses, half a teaspoonful each of salt and cinnamon, half a cupful of sugar and two well beaten eggs.  Bake in a quick oven for two hours; at the end of the first half-hour, stir in one cupful of cold milk and one tart apple pared, cored and cut into dice.  Serve with cream.

Cranberry Pudding

Sift three cupfuls of flour with a half teaspoonful of salt and stir in a cupful of molasses, a small cupful of sour cream, two beaten eggs and half a teaspoonful of soda dissolved in a little boiling water.  Last of all, beat in a cupful and a half of halved cranberries thoroughly dredged with flour.   Turn into a greased mould and steam for at least two hours.  Eat with a hard sauce.


Scrape, wash and score in quarter-inch slices a quarter pound of salt pork.  Cover with boiling water and simmer till tender.  Add one pint lima beans and more water if needed.  When the beans are tender, add one pint sweet corn pulp.  Cook fifteen minutes, add two tablespoonfuls of butter and a half-cupful of  cream, one-quarter teaspoonful of pepper, salt if needed.  Pour the succotash into serving dish, slice the salt pork as scored and serve.  If dried beans and corn are used, they must be soaked over night in cold water.

A few recipes sent in by readers.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s